| Name | Pastor/Vicar | Date |
|---|---|---|
| Mayer, Daryl | Pastor | 1948 to 1952 |
| Wentzlaff, Lloyd | Vicar | 1952 to 1953 |
| Mueller, Willard | Vicar | 1953 to 1954 |
| Wentzlaff, Lloyd | Pastor | 1954 to 1993 |
| Ballentin, Richard | Vicar | 1968 to 1969 |
| Morgret, Frank | Vicar | 1969 to 1970 |
| Hoyer, Peter | Vicar | 1970 to 1971 |
| Krahn, Allan | Vicar | 1971 to 1972 |
| Lutz, Terry | Vicar | 1972 to 1973 |
| Moffat, Doug | Vicar | 1973 to 1974 |
| Dooling, Mickey | Lay Worker | 1978 to 1980 |
| Rosenau, Terry | Vicar | 1979 to 1980 |
| Schiemann, Martin | Visitation Pastor | 1979 to 1989 |
| Found, Phil | Lay Minister | 1980 to 1982 |
| Kuehn, Marcus | Vicar | 1982 to 1983 |
| Kuehn, Marcus | Assistant Pastor | 1983 to 2004 |
| Mitchell, Jerry | Assistant Pastor | 1990 to 1994 |
| Bugbee, Robert | Senior Pastor | 1994 to 2010 |
| Schafer, Henrietta | Dir. Parish Services | 1997 to 2003 |
| Syens, Roland | Assistant Pastor | 2005 to 2020 |
| Winger, Roger | Visitation Pastor | 2008 to 2020 |
| Schafer, Henrietta | Parish Assistant | 2015 to 2023 |
| Astley, Nolan | Senior Pastor | 2010 to Present |
| Chuol, William | Nuer Pastor | 2017 to Present |
| Simpson, Lenora | Dir. Parish Services | 2017 to Present |
| Zabel, Paul | Visitation Pastor | 2020 to Present |
| Roggow, Paul | Associate Pastor | 2023 to Present |
Ministry Graduates from Holy Cross: Allan Scharlach, Don Schiemann, David Bode, William Kraemer, Kurt Lantz, William Stanfel
LBT Missionaries from Holy Cross: Robert/Jean Schmitt